VPN da proxy shine kwatancen hanyoyi guda biyu na jagorantar zirga-zirga ta wani sabar: VPN (tashar sirri ta zamani) yawanci yana ɓoye dukkan zirga-zirgar intanet na na'ura a cikin tunel zuwa sabar VPN, yayin da proxy ke turawa kawai ga aikace-aikacen da aka saita don amfani da shi kuma ba lallai ne ya ɓoye shi ba. Tare da kowanne daga cikin su, shafukan yanar gizo suna ganin adireshin IP na sabar maimakon naka.

VPN da Proxy a Kallo na Farko

VPNProxy
Abinda ya rufeDukkan zirga-zirgar intanet a kan na'uraKawai aikace-aikacen da aka saita don amfani da shi, kamar mai bincike ko mai cire bayanai
ɓoyewaYawanci yana ɓoye zirga-zirgar zuwa sabar VPNBa lallai ne ya ɓoye zirga-zirgar zuwa proxy ba
Yadda yake aikiYana tunel ɗin fakitin IP (misali IPsec ko WireGuard)Yana turawa da bukatun aikace-aikace (misali HTTP ko SOCKS5)
Adireshin IP da shafukan ke ganiNa sabar VPNNa proxy
Wanda zai iya ganin zirga-zirgar kaMai bayar da VPNMai gudanar da proxy, ciki har da duk wani HTTP da ba a ɓoye ba
IPs a lokaci gudaSabar guda ɗaya a kowanne haɗiProxy daban-daban a kowanne aikace-aikace ko zaman
Amfani na yau da kullumHanyoyin da ba a yarda da su ba kamar Wi-Fi na jama'a; hanyoyin sirri tsakanin hanyoyin sadarwaCire bayanai daga yanar gizo, jujjuyawar IP, nuni na yanki, gwaji

Yadda VPN ke Aiki

NIST yana bayyana VPN a matsayin hanyar sadarwa ta zamani da aka gina a kan hanyoyin sadarwa da ke akwai wanda ke ba da sadarwa mai tsaro tsakanin hanyoyin sadarwa ko tsakanin na'urori. Aikace-aikacen VPN yana tura zirga-zirgar na'ura ta hanyar tunel mai ɓoye zuwa sabar VPN, wanda ke turawa zuwa intanet. Hanyoyin da aka saba sun haɗa da IPsec, wanda NIST ke kira tsaro na matakin hanyar sadarwa, da WireGuard, wanda ke rufewa fakitin IP akan UDP. FTC ta lura cewa shigar da aikace-aikacen VPN yana ba shi izinin kama duk zirga-zirgar intanet naka.

Yadda Proxy ke Aiki

Ka'idar HTTP, RFC 9110, tana bayyana proxy a matsayin wakilin turawa saƙo da abokin ciniki ya zaɓa, yawanci ta hanyar ƙa'idodin saiti na gida. Kowanne aikace-aikace yana yanke shawarar ko zai yi amfani da shi: mai bincike ta hanyar saitunan haɗin sa, wani rubutu ta hanyar lambar sa.

  • HTTP proxies suna turawa da bukatun yanar gizo. Don shafukan HTTPS, abokin ciniki yana buɗe tunel CONNECT, kuma proxy yana aiki a matsayin mai jujjuya makaho wanda ba ya canza saƙonnin.
  • SOCKS5 proxies suna jujjuya zirga-zirgar TCP da UDP don kowanne aikace-aikacen da ke goyon bayan SOCKS.
  • Forward proxies na iya ɓoye adireshin IP na masu amfani, bisa ga MDN. Tor, misali, yana jagorantar zirga-zirgar ta hanyar proxies da yawa.

ɓoyewa: Abinda VPN ke ƙara akan HTTPS

A shafin HTTPS, haɗin yana riga yana da kariya ta TLS, wanda aka tsara don hana jin ra'ayi, canji da ƙirƙirar saƙo tsakanin na'urar ka da shafin. Wannan kariya tana wucewa ta hanyar proxy ba tare da canji ba. VPN yana ƙara ɓoyewa tsakanin na'urar ka da sabar VPN don duk zirga-zirgar, gami da HTTP mai sauƙi da aikace-aikacen da ba na yanar gizo ba. FTC ta ce wannan yawanci yana ɓoye abun cikin zirga-zirgar ka daga mai bayar da intanet naka ko mai bayar da Wi-Fi na jama'a. Ta hanyar proxy, HTTP mai sauƙi ba a ɓoye shi ba, kuma proxy na iya karanta ko canza shi.

Fitarwa da Zai Iya Bayyana Gaskiyar IP Dinka

  • DNS bincike: wani app na iya aika zirga-zirga ta hanyar SOCKS5 proxy amma har yanzu yana iya warware sunayen mai masauki da kansa, wanda ke haifar da DNS leak. A cikin curl, socks5h:// yana sa proxy ya warware sunaye maimakon haka.
  • WebRTC: masu bincike suna bayyana adireshin IP da WebRTC ke tattarawa ga kowanne shafi, don haka WebRTC leak na iya nuna ainihin IP dinka a bayan proxy na mai bincike.
  • Headers: wasu HTTP proxies suna ƙara X-Forwarded-For, wanda zai iya ɗaukar asalin adireshin IP na abokin ciniki.

Sirri da Amincewa a cikin Mai Gudanarwa

Duk VPN da proxy suna canza amincewa daga mai bayar da intanet naka zuwa wanda ke gudanar da sabar.

  • VPN encryption yana bambanta: FTC ta gano cewa wasu VPN apps ba su yi amfani da ɓoyewa ba, ko kuma sun ɓoye kawai wani ɓangare na zirga-zirga.
  • Ayyuka kyauta: wasu kyaututtukan VPN suna raba bayanan masu amfani tare da ƙungiyoyi na uku ko kuma suna canza zirga-zirga ta hanyar su, misali don nuna talla. MDN ta lura cewa akwai yiwuwar dubban dubban buɗaɗɗen proxies masu ci gaba a kan intanet.
  • Ba cikakken ɓoyewa ba: VPN ba ya sa ka zama cikakken ɓoyayye. Shafukan da kake ziyarta na iya iya gaya maka kana amfani da shi, kuma bayanan da ka ba su, kamar adireshin imel, na iya har yanzu tantance ka.

Yaushe za a Yi Amfani da VPN ko Proxy

  • Yi amfani da VPN lokacin da kake son ɓoyewa duk zirga-zirgar app a kan hanyar sadarwa da ba ka yarda da ita ba, kamar Wi-Fi na jama'a.
  • Yi amfani da proxy lokacin da wani app ke buƙatar takamaiman adireshin IP ko wuri, ko adireshin da yawa a lokaci guda. Saboda proxy yana saita bisa ga abokin ciniki, wani rubutun scraping na iya aika kowanne zaman ta hanyar adireshin daban. Wannan shine tushen proxy pools da IP rotation.
  • Saurin: duka biyun ba koyaushe suna da sauri ba. Nisa yana daya daga cikin manyan dalilan jinkirin hanyar sadarwa, don haka wurin sabar yana da mahimmanci ga duka.

Amfani da VPN da Proxy Tare

Zaka iya gudanar da duka. VPN yana tunanin zirga-zirgar na'urar, yayin da proxy settings ke aiki kawai ga apps da ke amfani da su. Tare da duka a kan, haɗin app zuwa proxy yana tafiya cikin tunanin VPN, kuma shafin yanar gizon yana ganin adireshin IP na proxy. Hanyar ta hanyar wasu masu tsaka-tsaki a jere ana kiranta proxy chain.

Sharuɗɗan da suka shafi